Well, after not getting a response from Stag, I went ahead and ordered the PRI 6.8 SPC extractor from Midway for $28 including shipping.
Got it yesterday and did a comparison to one of the 5.56 extractors from my spare parts box. The groove width appears to be identical at around .065" (crude measuring with feeler gauges) as well as the depth of the cutout. The only thing I can think may be slightly different is the radius of the groove for the larger diameter case, but I have no way to measure that and I can't see a visual difference.
Appears I paid almost twice as much as I needed to when I could have just gotten a 5.56 one from Brownells for about $15 or used the one from my parts box. Should have waited for the expert (Tim_W) to jump in before ordering. Oh well, guess it can't hurt to have some extra parts lying around. Only problem is, they usually end up turning themselves into complete rifles at some point.
So, why does PRI sell a unique extractor for 6.8?